A cheesecake inspired by Superman ice cream ranks among the most talked-about slices at one Michigan bakery. Yes, that red, yellow and blue flavor many of us begged for as kids.
That slice shares the spotlight with banana pudding, sweet potato, peach cobbler and caramel apple cheesecakes. Then come crunch cakes, peanut butter cookies and cheesecake cannolis, which honestly feels like a friendly dare.
I like how this shop sells individual slices, not just whole cakes. You can stop by on a Tuesday evening and leave with three flavors instead of agonizing over one.
I believe that’s the smartest way to handle any dessert decision.
The bakery sits along a busy suburban road just north of Detroit. It also holds a 4.6-star Google rating across more than 700 reviews.
So which slice would you grab first, and how many would survive the drive home?
A Cheesecake Counter Worth Knowing On Nine Mile
Oak Park doesn’t usually top the list when Michiganders talk dessert road trips. Peteet’s Famous Cheesecakes makes a strong case for changing that.
The shop sits on Nine Mile Road in a compact suburb that borders Detroit’s northern edge. Google lists it as a cupcake shop, which is technically true and wildly incomplete.
Cheesecake runs the show here, and the case usually holds a big selection of slices. Full-size cakes are also available, but those typically need a preorder ahead of time.
Fans keep returning to a handful of names. Superman, banana pudding, sweet potato and peach cobbler pop up again and again in conversations about the place.
That variety is the whole appeal. You aren’t committing to one giant cake and hoping for the best.
Instead, you can mix and match slices like a kid choosing candy at the corner store. It’s a very Michigan kind of treat run, casual and local and quietly impressive.
The shop also earns a 4.6-star rating across 711 Google reviews. For a small neighborhood bakery, that’s a lot of people bothering to say something nice.
The Family Name Behind Every Slice
Patrick Peteet signs his name to the bakery’s replies online, and he signs it as the owner. That small detail tells you plenty about how personal the business feels.
His name is literally on the door. When a shop is called Peteet’s Famous Cheesecakes, every slice carries a family reputation along with it.
Customers have described meeting the owner and his wife behind the counter. They come across as warm, friendly people who clearly care about what leaves the kitchen.
The family connection stretches beyond the store, too. The owner and his children have handed out samples at a family fun day at Seneca Park.
Picture getting a free bite of cheesecake at a park event and then hunting down the bakery. That’s exactly how some loyal customers say they found their new favorite dessert stop.
Owner replies often end with a request to spread the word to friends and family. It’s an old-school approach, built on handshakes and neighbors talking.
In a world of chain bakeries, that grassroots style feels refreshing. It’s the kind of small Michigan business people genuinely enjoy cheering for.
Superman Ice Cream Grew Up And Became Cheesecake
Red, yellow and blue. If you grew up in Michigan, those colors probably mean one thing, and it isn’t a comic book.
Superman ice cream is a true Midwest childhood staple. Peteet’s turned that nostalgic flavor into one of its most popular cheesecake slices.
The bright swirls make it impossible to miss in the case. It’s the slice that grabs kids’ attention and quietly wins over the adults standing next to them.
One customer said a Superman crunch cake really did remind them of the famous ice cream. They called the cake moist and praised the cheesecake-flavored icing.
The Superman theme doesn’t stop at cheesecake, either. There’s a Superman crumb cake, plus Superman cookies for anyone who wants a handheld version.
Some visitors can’t choose between the crumb cake and cheesecake versions. So they grab both and hold their own taste test at the table.
Honestly, that sounds like the best kind of homework. Bring a friend, split two Superman slices and settle the debate yourselves.
Fair warning, you might need a rematch. Nobody seems to stop at one round.
Banana Pudding And Sweet Potato Steal The Spotlight
Banana pudding gets mentioned more than almost anything else at the shop. Sweet potato pie follows right behind it, which says a lot about this crowd’s taste.
Both are classic comfort desserts with deep roots in family kitchens and church gatherings. Peteet’s honors them while adding its own cheesecake spin.
Sweet potato cheesecake earns its own loyal following. Longtime supporters list it right alongside Superman as a top favorite.
Banana shows up in more than one form. There’s banana pudding by the cup, plus a banana pudding crunch cake with cheesecake layers tucked inside.
That crunch cake has fans calling it one of the best cakes they’ve ever eaten. Those are bold words for any bakery to live up to.
A quick tip feels fair here. Banana pudding tastes best fresh, so ask about the newest batch when you order.
Sweet potato pie also sells on its own if you want the original classic. Grabbing one of each feels like the responsible choice.
Call it research. Your dessert plate deserves a proper side-by-side comparison.
Peach Cobbler, Caramel Apple And A Whole Rainbow Of Flavors
Peach cobbler cheesecake might be the most dangerous slice in the building. One fan called it their absolute favorite dessert ever, which is quite the endorsement.
It blends two summer-picnic icons into one forkful. If cobbler was a staple at your grandma’s table, it’ll feel familiar right away.
Caramel apple cheesecake is another crowd-pleaser, especially when Michigan’s orchard season rolls around. Apple country loves a good apple dessert, after all.
Key lime and red velvet bring some brightness and color to the lineup. Strawberry offers a classic option, and plain cheesecake still holds its own.
In fact, one longtime fan said plain remains their top pick. Sometimes the simple version proves the baker really knows the basics.
Turtle and strawberry banana have also earned shoutouts from excited customers. One visitor went back inside three times just to try more flavors.
Flavor availability can shift, so the case may look a little different each visit. That makes every stop feel like a small surprise.
Go in with a favorite in mind, but stay flexible. The best slice might be one you never planned to order.
Crunch Cakes, Cannolis And Cookies Deserve Equal Attention
Cheesecake gets the famous label, but the supporting cast refuses to stay in the background. Some fans arrive for cheesecake and leave obsessed with something else.
Strawberry crunch cake stands out among the non-cheesecake treats. That crunchy coating brings back memories of a certain ice cream truck bar.
Then there are the cheesecake cannolis. It’s a clever mashup that blends an Italian classic with the shop’s specialty filling.
Carrot cake and red velvet cake also show up among the popular picks. Both are reliable choices when you’re buying for a crowd with mixed tastes.
Cookies deserve a special mention. One customer called the peanut butter cookies the best they’d ever tasted, and that’s no small claim.
The cheesecake cupcake is another sneaky winner. It’s described as moist and flavorful with a generous amount of cheesecake inside.
Crumb cake rounds things out for anyone who prefers a buttery, crumbly bite. The Superman version proves the shop loves a good theme.
So yes, the menu stretches far past slices. Leave room on the counter, because your bag will probably get heavier than planned.
Friendly Faces And A Clean, Cozy Counter
Clean, organized and welcoming are words that come up often when people describe the shop. That’s a nice combination when you’re about to spend real time staring at dessert.
The interior is described as beautiful, with a good selection front and center. You’ll know exactly where to look the moment you arrive.
Staff warmth gets plenty of credit, too. Several customers mention a team member named Tonia, praising her for great service and good laughs.
One fan put it simply, saying you get cheesecake, a smile and a laugh. Honestly, that’s a pretty great deal for one stop.
Service moves quickly, so it works well for a fast weeknight treat run. Carryout is described as efficient, which helps when the after-dinner craving hits.
A few tables let you eat on-site if you can’t wait. That’s handy for anyone who knows a slice won’t survive the car ride.
Families, couples on a casual date and solo dessert hunters all fit right in here. It’s relaxed, neighborly and refreshingly unfussy.
Like any busy shop, experiences can vary. Still, the overall tone leans warm and friendly.
You Might Spot These Desserts Far Beyond Oak Park
Sometimes a great dessert finds you before you find the bakery. Some people first tried Peteet’s at a restaurant across town, not at the shop.
The banana pudding crunch cake is sold at Captain Jay’s locations. One fan tried it there and couldn’t wait to visit the actual bakery.
Local television has noticed, too. Peteet’s appeared on FOX 2 in Detroit, and viewers said everything looked delicious.
That kind of exposure brings new faces through the door. For a family-run Michigan bakery, it’s a big moment worth celebrating.
The shop also shows up for community events. The owner and his children have handed out samples at a family fun day in Seneca Park.
National Cheesecake Day becomes its own party here. In past years, the shop handed out a free celebration slice to mark the occasion.
Promotions can change from year to year, so check before planning around one. Still, it’s a fun date to keep on your summer calendar.
All of that helps explain the loyal following. People love supporting a local name that keeps showing up for them.
Hours, Parking And Ordering Before You Head Over
Good news for late-afternoon cravings: most weekdays run until 7 PM. That gives you time to swing by after work or school pickup.
Monday through Friday, hours are listed as 10 AM to 7 PM. Saturday runs 11 AM to 6 PM, and Sunday is noon to 5 PM.
Hours may shift around holidays, so a quick check before driving is smart. Nobody wants to stare sadly at a locked door.
You’ll find Peteet’s Famous Cheesecakes at 13835 W Nine Mile Rd, Oak Park, MI 48237. It’s an easy drive from Detroit, Ferndale, Southfield and much of Oakland County.
Parking is available in front and along the side of the building. That makes quick stops much less stressful during busy times.
Slices are ready to grab in the case for walk-in visits. Whole cheesecakes typically need a preorder, so plan ahead for birthdays and parties.
Prices are generally described as fair for the slice size. Slices are called large, so one may stretch further than expected.
A little planning goes a long way here. Your future self will be grateful.
Why Your Next Michigan Dessert Run Should End Here
Some desserts taste like a memory, and Peteet’s seems to understand that perfectly. Superman swirls, banana pudding and peach cobbler all carry a little hometown nostalgia.
That’s what makes Peteet’s Famous Cheesecakes worth the drive. It mixes family-run warmth with flavors that feel deeply rooted in Michigan kitchens.
I love that you can sample several slices instead of betting everything on one. It turns a quick bakery stop into a small adventure.
Bring a friend and split a box. That way, you can debate Superman versus sweet potato without anyone going home disappointed.
It works for birthdays, too, as long as you preorder a whole cake. Plenty of families have trusted it for big celebrations.
Is every visit flawless? Probably not, since no bakery is perfect, but the overall goodwill speaks loudly.
With a 4.6-star rating and a steady stream of fans, the shop has earned its spot. Oak Park should be proud of this sweet neighborhood landmark.
So next time you’re near Nine Mile, make the detour. Just don’t expect half your slices to survive the ride home.
